What if There Were No Heaven?

(This post originally appeared on the now defunct centurybound.com blog on December 22, 2005. It appears here with some major rewrites from the author.)

While surfing the internet, I happened upon the blog of an atheist who was asking the following question of her readers:

“How many people would believe in a god if there were no rewards promised to the self for doing so?”

This rather loaded question is a complicated one. It is actually not meant to be a question, but rather an attack on the principles of Christianity. The atheist is suggesting that the Christian faith is a selfish one and insinuating that if there were no promise of Heaven, there would be few, if any, Christians. There is no chance I could ever answer the question to this particular atheist’s satisfaction because I suspect she believes she already knows the answer. Furthermore, I’m not sure there is a way to know the answer. Since there is a promise of Heaven, I have no idea how many Christians there would be if that promise was ripped out from under us. I suspect, rather sadly, there would be less. Possibly much less, but that is just a guess. I know that in my own experience, Heaven did not enter the equation. I chose to believe in God because I had an encounter with Him that began to make sense to me intellectually. I then chose to believe in Jesus Christ (and the Christian faith) specifically for an abundance of reasons – none of which were Heaven. I sort of see Heaven as the icing on the cake. Don’t get me wrong, I am glad the promise is there; but my faith doesn’t hinge on it.

I believe we can examine this question introspectively in a way that can help us examine our faith. What if today, we pondered the following question?

Would you still follow Jesus Christ if there were suddenly no promise of Heaven?

If our answer to this question is ‘no’, I would suggest that we may be on shaky ground spiritually. I spent the majority of life before Christ creating a particular version of God in my mind and then imposing those values on the real God. For instance, the God I created was all knowing and all powerful. He had created this world and then stepped back to see what would happen. He was a fair God who would allow pretty much anyone into Heaven provided they tried to live a good life (you know … paid their taxes, supported their children, didn’t kill anyone … that sort of thing). It was only when I humbled myself that I realized I had no right to impose my beliefs on God. If God were real, I had to allow Him to teach me about Himself and accept even what I didn’t understand. I had no business trying to invent God in my image. I had to understand and apply the old saying “Father Knows Best.” In other words, if God, in all His wisdom, suddenly decided there should be no Heaven, I would have to accept it – even if I didn’t understand it. I can’t worship God because of what He promises me, rather, I must worship God because He deserves it.

I am so thankful that my God has promised me Heaven. I also believe there is a hell. Hell, in my opinion, is proof that God loves us. How’s that you might ask? Well, if what we really want is a place that is free from the presence and influence of God, he will provide it for us even though it breaks His heart to do so. That place is hell. It’s not God that makes hell such a terrible place … it is the complete absence of God’s influence that makes hell so bad.

Even though I have a concrete belief in Heaven and hell, I can’t make that the focal point of my faith. Why? Well, if all I do is think about the future … someday far in the future … I am ignoring one of Jesus’ most powerful lessons. Jesus taught that the Kingdom of Heaven is near. What did He mean by that? I think He meant that we can experience Heaven right now in our mortal life. If hell is the total absence of God, then Heaven is living in God’s presence. In fact, Heaven is more than just the presence of God – it is a place where God’s Will is done. We can experience God’s presence and live in His will right now. If we spend all of our time looking towards the future, we will miss out on the beauty that is Heaven on Earth.

Think about it … we all know the bitter and depressed Christian who lives a miserable life and constantly talks about Heaven in the future tense. My heart goes out to these people. Thank God they have the promise of eternal life from the One True God to keep them going. I am not suggesting that it would be healthy to totally forget about our promise of Heaven; I just pray that someday we can all experience a shadow of Heaven right now!


2 thoughts on “What if There Were No Heaven?

  1. Stefanie Goble February 18, 2010 / 3:48 pm


    I’ve often pondered this question in my own life. Many Christians use fear as a motivational tool to convert sinners. My Mother was quite effective at using fear as a control mechanism and justification for abusing her children. What I have determined is that a person could not survive starvation, physical abuse, sexual abuse, verbal abuse, and constant fear of death at the hands of a parent unless God looked after them. I have no explanation other than meeting Jesus as a child on a personal level. Adopting God as my only Father figure was a life changing moment. Psychologically speaking, I should be insane but I’m not. My children should have been susceptible to abuse because children tend to do as adults what they had done. Many molesters in prisons were molested as children. If heaven were not promised, I would still need Jesus to have peace. The joy I experience at seeing my children grow in a loving home free of abuse is so special to me. Many Christians do appear bitter and judgmental but many do not either. The Christians that shared the unconditional love of a God that wanted the very best for me seemed so peaceful. I have joy in my marriage to you that has exceeded my expectations. We share that joy and love with our children. You once exhibited the greatest version of God’s love that I have ever seen exhibited. When your daughter was messing up left and right, you said simply, “Everyone deserves a do over in life. This is yours”. It changed her whole persona to be loved that unconditionally. The greatest gift Christ has given me is that when I screw up and beat myself up, he runs to me and lifts up my tear stained face and lovingly says, “Everybody deserves a do over”. The woman caught in the act of adultery found freedom in the Bible when everyone wanted to stone her. Jesus said, “Let he who is without sin cast the first stone”. In one sentence he set her free. It is the only true freedom that exists. You don’t have to be incarcerated to be in bondage. He came to show us how to truly live. To have peace when a radiologist says you might have Cancer. To take away my fear and let me have joy…that IS HEAVEN!

    Stefanie Goble


  2. Ty February 22, 2010 / 11:54 pm

    Jews don’t generally have the same promise of Heaven as do Christians and there are still millions of them, though some Jews do believe in Heaven or an afterlife of sorts while other Jews believe in a future where God (or a messiah figure) will rule directly on Earth. And some Jews believe in both. Official (so to speak) Judaism isn’t exactly clear on the subject, at least not in English translations.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s